It's my story, but at the same time it isn't.
It's my grief, it's my pain, it's my trauma.
It's the worst day of my life thus far, and I know it is shared with dozens of others.
A year has gone by with all of its seasons and changes and growth, yet almost every day of it has had an underlying aroma of November 9th, 2012.
Here is my story. It has never changed, it matches my police report seamlessly, and I refuse to fill in the gaps of my memory with assumptions or inferences.
I have changed the names of those involved so as to respect their privacy to my potential readers who do not know them. I will remove this post if they become aware of its existence and are uncomfortable with it.
I am writing this to externalize what happened, because for a year it has felt like something that happened within my very being and has never left. I wish to be free of the fear and the darkness that coat those memories for me. I want to grieve properly.
November 9th, 2012 was a Friday. I remember looking at my weather app a few days before and seeing that, after consistent forecasts of 90ish degree days, Friday was supposed to drop down to 72 degrees. The next day was supposed to be as low as 64! For Phoenix, this is a huge deal worth celebrating. The day came and it was as brisk as I eagerly expected. I also had a friend's wedding to go to after work that I planned on asking to leave early for.
Around noon, Luke brought Sybil to the house like he always did. Of course, we were all in the office busy with work (I worked for a family business run out of the older married owners Jack and Barb's home; Luke is their son in his 40s and was a close friend of mine). Sybil immediately began running around and squealing like she usually did -- like most three-year-olds do. He was dropping her off in order to go home, get dressed up, and officiate the very wedding I wanted to go to that afternoon. I hoped this would work in my favor in asking for the hour shaved off my work day.
In retrospect, it seems like every conversation we had while inputting this, printing off that, filing this away...they were all about Sybil. Barb, my co-worker Lisa and I talked about how Luke and his wife Lori waited so long (fifteen years) to have Sybil as their first child (their only child). The company salesman John commented lovingly on how cute Sybil looked that day ("I mean she's always cute but today she is just SO CUTE!"). She was playing with her toys in the kitchen next to the doorway into our office, and usually I just tried to ignore the distraction to focus on all the math I had to do as an accountant, but that day I stopped and watched her for a moment. I remember consciously thinking she reminded me of my precious niece Maddy, who was also three at the time. They shared the same mannerisms, speech patterns, and snuggly demands from people they approved of. Such a joy, such a gift, such a warm and comforting little tea light of a human.
I never had an intimate interaction with Sybil. We had played and tickled and made faces at each other over the years, but I know she didn't know who I was or had a name for me. But she reminded me of one of my most cherished humans, Maddy, and that was enough to award her a quaint little corner in my heart. I loved having her around, and I loved watching my dear friends Luke and Lori be her parents.
Around 2pm or so, Sybil's 'Papa' Jack took her outside to play with her. They did this all the time. She had a swing and toys out there, and Jack had even remodeled his backyard to feel like a garden around their pool for Sybil to enjoy. All I was actively thinking about at the time was when I should tactfully ask Barb, sitting in the desk across the room from me, if I could leave an hour early that day.
Around 3:30pm, my stress was elevated ever so slightly because the time was approaching to ask Barb if I could leave early for the wedding. I kept wondering how I should phrase it, when I should ask, if I should ask at all and just show up late, etc. Jack came in from outside and I heard him in the kitchen while I thought through all my strategies. From her desk, Barb casually said, "Jack you need to bring Sybil in for a nap or else she'll get cranky."
Sybil's still outside? And Jack is inside? She's outside alone?
"Yeah I know, I'll bring her in now." He went back outside.
I felt the smallest little pluck of fear but let it rest. Barb and Jack had babysat Sybil her entire life, at least once a week probably. They know her, Luke and Lori trust them, Barb doesn't seem anxious about the situation, everything's fine.
Everything's fine.
I wonder when I should ask about the wedd-
"BARB!!!!! BARB CALL 9-1-1!!!!!!!"
Jack was screaming from outside. He flung the back door open and it slammed against the wall.
A second "BARB CALL 9-1-1!!!!!!" echoed throughout the tiled house.
We all jolted our heads up with adrenaline. I sat closest to the office door that opened to the kitchen with windows on every wall facing the backyard. I believe I saw it first after his initial scream.
I saw a drenched Jack running from the back door to yell for Barb to call 9-1-1, and saw a limp, soaking wet, unconscious Sybil in his arms.
Oh my God. She fell in the pool.
Barb leapt up from her desk and ran to the office door, letting out an "Oh GOD!!" the moment she saw what I saw.
Lisa got out of her chair before me. When she saw the situation she grabbed the back of my chair and frantically said, "I knew this was going to happen today. I KNEW it!!" with a look of horror on her face, shaking my chair a few times before running to the back door.
I couldn't move.
I couldn't think.
...what?
I sat there for a moment longer and then slowly got up and walked outside.
Sybil was lying on a pool float on the deck.
Jack was kneeling down doing compressions on Sybil's tiny chest.
John was kneeling down next to Jack, counting the compressions for him.
Barb was pacing, crying, talking to herself, yelling at Sybil to wake up.
Lisa was pacing, crying, taking deep breaths, had a hand pressed to her forehead.
I was emotionlessly looking around, assessing the situation, trying to find a way I could help.
what?
Jack panically asked Barb if she'd called 9-1-1 yet.
In her despair, she hadn't.
I found my way to help.
I made the first 9-1-1 call in my whole life.
The operator patched me through to a paramedic. He told me to stay on the line with him until the paramedics came to the house. He asked me to describe the situation.
Me: Right now she is laying down on the pool deck and her grandpa is doing compressions.
Paramedic: Is any water coming out of her nose or mouth?
Me: No, just some runny white stuff is coming out of her nose.
Parademic: Okay, make sure that's getting pushed away from her nose as it's coming out.
I tell John to start pushing away the white stuff.
Paramedic: How many compressions is her grandpa doing before trying to breathe for her?
Me: I'm not sure.
Paramedic: Okay, make sure it's thirty compressions, then two full breaths into her mouth with her nose pinched.
I tell John to tell Jack to make sure it's thirty compressions then two breaths.
Me: Okay I told them. Thank you so much.
Paramedic: You're welcome, but don't hang up yet.
Me: Oh I know, I'm not. Just, thank you.
Paramedic: You're welcome.
I heard sirens. The paramedics came blazing down the road. They ran into the front door that was already open and into the back yard and quickly began working. I told the phone paramedic they arrived, thanked him again, and hung up.
Once they took over for Jack and John, Jack had no choice but to stand aside helplessly in all of his horror and sorrow. He crumpled to his knees and wept.
I rested my head on one of the walls of the house and quietly prayed. Please...please...please...it's all I could muster.
I eventually looked around and saw Lisa comforting Barb on the porch. I went over to them. Lisa was more composed, but Barb had only gotten worse. Lisa was also trying to call Luke, who hadn't answered her first few calls. It then became my job to get in touch with someone in the wedding party to let them know Luke couldn't officiate, and if he'd already arrived then he needed to answer his phone and leave.
Lisa got a hold of Luke before I got anyone.
"Luke, Sybil fell into the pool and the paramedics are here. You need to get over here now."
...
"No, it's not a joke. You need to get over here now."
...
"I know, I'm so sorry. You need to get over here now."
I won't repeat what Lisa told me he was saying, or how she heard Lori responding in the background. It isn't my memory to share. But it was clear that they felt the terror of the situation.
I then set out to get ahold of anyone at the wedding whose number I had.
I tried the groom. No answer, of course.
I tried one groomsman. Another groomsman. A bridesmaid.
The second bridesmaid I tried answered. Anna.
"Hey Anna, it's Katelyn. I'm calling because I need you and the rest of the wedding party to know that today, at Jack and Barb's house, Sybil fell in the pool and hasn't woken up yet...
Finally, the tears shot up from within me like a flash flood.
...so we need you guys to pray your hearts out, and that also means Luke can't be there today."
She responded calmly, let me know they would pray hard, and they'd figure out the wedding details. We hung up.
I found a corner of the backyard not occupied or visible to anyone else and sat on the ground, my back to the wall, and let the tears come.
I know this happens sometimes, Jesus. I know this happens to people. But please, please not today, not Sybil, not this family. Please...
After a few minutes, I heard a helicopter get louder and louder until it sounded like it was ten feet away from me. I got up and saw that a medical helicopter had landed on their street. I walked around to where everyone was and saw that they'd put Sybil onto a stretcher and were breathing for her with a bag. She was being wheeled through the backyard fence door to the chopper, and Jack and Barb were preparing to be driven to the hospital. They had contacted Luke and Lori to meet them there and not at the house. I never saw Luke or Lori that day.
Barb and Jack soon left, and all that were left in the house were myself, Lisa, John, and the policemen who had arrived at some point. Suddenly, coming from upstairs was Ben, Jack and Barb's grandson, Sybil's cousin. He had been out cold in a nap and had no idea what was going on. We told him as much about the situation as we knew. He quietly began to cry.
We each gave our statement and we talked amongst ourselves as detectives went to the backyard and neighbors/news crews slowly turned up in front of the house.
We were told we could leave whenever we liked, but we didn't have to.
Ben left for the hospital as soon as he could. He said he would call us with any update he could give.
John left before Lisa and I.
Barb called Lisa a few times for this and that, asked her if she could call Lori's sister and their church pastor to let them know about the situation. We decided to stay for awhile in case Barb needed any more information from her house.
5pm passed. Lisa and I turned on the news to see if any reports had come up yet. She explained why she'd said earlier "I knew this would happen today," and it was because she had envisioned seeing Jack crying with Sybil unconscious in his arms. She couldn't explain it, and it had bothered her earlier that day.
I was on Facebook on my phone and saw that Luke had posted a status of "Please pray for Sybil. She is in critical condition. Pleeaaaassseeee praaaaayyyyy."
This actually gave me hope.
Critical condition = Alive!
Praise Jesus, she just needs to recover. Even if it's never the same again, she's alive she's alive she's alive.
I texted a few close friends about the situation. I texted my sister and my mom. My mom was at the wedding I wanted to be at, and I knew she'd relay any information I gave her.
We waited for an update from Ben.
6pm came. It was starting to get dark outside. Lisa got a call from Ben, and this is what I remember:
"Hi Ben, what's going on?
...
...
...
*Lisa looks at me*
...
...oh no, she died?"
Fuck.
I got up off the sofa...walked around...took deep breaths...then sat on the fireplace bench and put my head between my legs, breathing deeply.
"I'm so sorry Ben..."
No. It doesn't make sense.
"Let us know if you need anything."
No...
She hung up. We sat there awhile. We talked some.
But we both knew it was over. And it was time to go home.
I called my mom from Jack and Barb's living room, and I felt the surge of emotion choking me again when I told her Sybil had passed away. She was heartbroken too and asked if I wanted her to meet me at my house. I knew I'd be the only one home, and that's the last thing I wanted. I wanted to be around people I loved, and most of them were at the wedding I'd wanted so desperately to be at. She told me to come on over, that they were preparing for the reception now.
With Lisa by my side, we left the house and didn't make eye contact with any of the gawking neighbors or news crews. We both got in our cars and drove away.
I went to the wedding, but left early.
And the following day was just as cold as I'd been anticipating, though it brought no joy. It felt more like an absence from warmth than any other cold I've experienced.
The rest is history. The rest needs to be sorted out with a counselor I plan to find soon.
Sorting through that day has been one of the hardest attempts in my life. It left me cold, quiet, and alone.
It left me with the dead body of a beautiful three-year-old girl laying at the shores of all my experiences last year.
She lies within the caves of my deepest being.
I have tried not to glance over at her when I'm trying my best to feel joy in my veins and really laugh without hesitation.
But she's there. She's laying right there, wearing those purple patterned tights with that purple long-sleeved shirt to match.
And sometimes, without my permission or warning, I can feel her drop into the cold water and take a big breath out of fear, allowing the water into her lungs and causing her to suffocate until she must've lost consciousness.
That moment plays like a broken record in my mind -- an innocent little love choking to death.
Needless to say, God and I have had some honest, profane, emotional, and outright blasphemous talks since then. I've thought things, done things, said things I'm not proud of since then. And I know now that it's because I felt His absence so profoundly in that moment, the worst trauma of my life, that I couldn't bear His presence afterward.
We're working on that now; I feel like I finally have strength for it. I'm making time for His Word, for other good books, investing in healthy friendships and seeking out counseling.
This post is part of that therapeutic experience.
I want to lay to rest the Sybil that lies dead within me, just like the real Sybil was laid to rest.
I want to externalize my personal experience and not have it be an albatross around my neck.
This happened. But it's over now.
I don't wish to forget her, but I wish for her memory in me to be more about who she was than how she died.
This is my funeral service, my eulogy, my prayer for her.
Photo by Katy Horgan
Hi there little love,
You were such a goof, and you helped me be goofy too. You seemed so incredibly aware of the love we all felt for you, and you used up your whole heart in your love back to us. Even in your sassiest times, you only wanted more time with your people - no more naps or bedtimes! Even when you got upset over things not going your way, it was only you trying to figure out how things worked and why they weren't working the way you wanted them to. You brought your family so much joy, and those who loved your family were in turn blessed by you. You should have seen all the people who came to our service for you...we could all barely fit in the room! I'm so sorry you were scared when you fell in the pool, and I'm so sorry none of us knew that happened -- your Papa especially. Make sure to give him a big big hug when he meets you in Heaven, and let him know that you've helped prepare a place for him for eternity - maybe a garden for the two of you to play in. I am so glad that the whole experience was quick, and that you had such a vibrant, loving, and adventurous life while you were here. We miss you. We love you. We'll see you soon. Goodbye for now, little one.
Katelyn





